Each week two guests came to Fantasy Island to get their wish or fantasy fulfilled. The show was very similar to "The Love Boat" except their mysterious host was the debonair and suave white-suited Mr. Roarke played by Ricardo Montalban. He would do the sometimes impossible and grant them their wishes.

In this episode he assists Melissa Sue Anderson, playing Amy Marson, a young woman rendered mute by her mother's death. Mr. Roarke helps her find out whether her mom was responsible.