Police Rescue 140 Animals From Neglect Case in Pulaski, NY

A disturbing animal neglect investigation in Oswego County has led to the rescue of nearly 140 animals and the arrest of a Pulaski man who is now facing multiple charges.

Investigation Began With Concern for a Great Dane

According to New York State Police, the case began on December 19, 2025, after authorities received a report about a malnourished Great Dane at a home on State Route 3 in the town of Pulaski.

Troopers responded to the property and spoke with homeowner Jeffrey D. Zehr, who claimed the dog was suffering from worms and fleas. He was advised to seek veterinary care, and police planned a follow-up visit.

However, investigators say those follow-up attempts were unsuccessful, and Zehr became uncooperative.

Search Warrant Reveals Widespread Neglect

State Police finally secured a search warrant for the residence and the surrounding 87-acre property on March 13.

Authorities discovered approximately 140 animals living on the property, including several that were pregnant. Many of the animals were reportedly suffering from malnourishment, infections, and a lack of proper food, water, and shelter.

Veterinary teams on scene determined that at least 11 horses,15 goats, 8 sheep, 4 cats and 2 calves were being neglected and not receiving proper care.

Animals Removed With Help From Local Organizations

Due to the severity of the conditions, State Police coordinated with several local organizations to safely remove and treat the animals, including the Oswego County SPCA, Oswego Humane Society, and Kirkville Animal Rescue and Education (KARE).

Officials say the property itself was also in extremely poor condition, with unsanitary and unsafe living environments. The home was ultimately deemed unfit for human occupancy by local code enforcement.

Weapons Discovered During Search

During the execution of the warrant, investigators also located two .22 caliber rifles inside the residence.

Further investigation revealed that Zehr is a convicted felon, making it illegal for him to possess firearms.

Arrest and Charges Filed

On April 25, 2026, Zehr was arrested and charged with:

40 counts of animal cruelty for failure to provide proper sustenance
1 count of criminal possession of a weapon in the fourth degree

He was processed at State Police in Pulaski and issued an appearance ticket. He is scheduled to appear in Oswego County CAP Court on May 9.

Get our free mobile app

Anyone who suspects animal neglect or abuse is encouraged to report it to local authorities.

Plants That Can Turn Your Yard Into a Monarch Haven

You don’t need a massive garden to help.

Even planting a few of these in a small space can create a stop along the monarch’s migration route. And the more people who do it? The better chance these butterflies have to bounce back.

So if you’re planting this season, maybe skip one of the basic flowers, and go with something that actually gives back.

Tips for First-Time Birders in Central New York

New to birding? This quick-hit guide will help you get started like a pro. From the best times to go birdwatching to which apps to download (and yes—why you should skip the hot pink), these beginner-friendly tips are perfect for exploring the wild side of Central New York.

Gallery Credit: Unsplash/