This week's Throwdown Thursday is Katy Perry vs. The Script. We need your help to decide what music we should spotlight more. Which breakup song is the best this week?

Katy Perry with "The One That Got Away"



This sweet pop ballad about lost love finds KatyPerry and her guy falling in love, then falling out. The video shows the sad love story, and how it plays out. "Sometimes you promise someone forever but it doesn't" work out that way.


The Script with “Nothing”



This ballad was written after a drunken phone call The Script's Danny O'Donoghue made to his girlfriend after they split up. He explained to The Sun September 3, 2010: "I was heartbroken and the last thing I needed was to be taken out for a drink. I ended up making a fool of myself by calling her when I was in such a state."